Saturday, December 12, 2009

December 2009: Obama’s Human Rights Policy

Annotation of

Obama’s speech to the United Nations General Assembly (September, 2009).

Does Obama believes in human rights? By Bret Stephens. The Wall Street Journal. October 19, 2009.


~ The Editors

Read More...

Hope over Experience?

by Cath Collins, Universidad Diego Portales, Santiago de Chile

“The option for genuine multilateralism, for leading the way in accepting the binding nature of international law and refusing to invoke the veto option whenever national interests are trimmed, is always there. But the US has consistently refused to take it. This is where Obama could make a difference(…)"

Read More...

Change We Can Believe In?

by Katherine Hite, Vassar College

"But it’s very hard not to be dismayed by some of the continuities from the Bush to the Obama administration (…). When it comes to US-Latin America relations, such decisions include: professing support for progressive immigration reform while expanding regressive anti-immigration measures; claiming a commitment to human rights and democratic engagement while facilitating increased military control over domestic affairs in the region; and voicing a desire for a multilateral approach to Latin American affairs while patently undermining such an approach."

Read More...

From Inspiring Hope to Taking Action: Obama and Human Rights

by Stephen James, La Trobe University

"While President George H. Bush spoke of a new world order, and his ‘misunderestimated’ son mangled the English language at countless press conferences, with Barack Obama the USA now has a talented orator as a president. There is a new word order. But does the new and skilful rhetoric match the reality when it comes to human rights?"

Read More...

The Statesman’s Dilemma: Peace or Justice? Or Neither?

by Henry Krisch, University of Connecticut

"What advice then to give President Obama regarding this difficult balance? I would suggest three modest steps: first, do what you can where you can and disregard universal consistency; second, link your criticism of human rights violations with the traditions and efforts of the people in a given country who are themselves fighting for change; finally, to the greatest extent possible, link our relations with this country with progress on human rights."

Read More...

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

November 2009: Human Rights in Peru

Annotation of
Healing the Past, Protecting the Future. By Alejandro Toledo. Americas Quarterly. July 13, 2009.
~ The Editors

Read More...

The Hidden Costs of Terror

by Cath Collins, Universidad Diego Portales, Santiago de Chile

“Torture, disappearance and rendition carried out in the name of a “war on terror” is now being exposed, repudiated and punished in the South. Will the North ever follow suit?”

Read More...

The Peruvian Precedent

by Katherine Hite, Vassar College

"The trade-off between truth and justice has not born out, however, and today hundreds of Chilean military human rights cases have been legally processed, and many human rights violators are behind bars. The Guatemalan generals are certainly not out of the woods. Peru has also powerfully defied this logic, best illustrated by the conviction of former president Alberto Fujimori. Let the fitful, volatile but persistent truth and justice process of Peru serve as a powerful global precedent"

Read More...

From Atrocities to Security: A Parable from Peru

by Stephen James, La Trobe University

"As with many cases of human rights violations, the victims in Peru were dehumanized before they were abused (…) To combat dehumanization, societies must re-humanize the vulnerable and the persecuted, including the victims of human rights violations. Truth commissions have a vital role to play in this re-humanization: they give a forum to victims, validating their testimony and providing them with some catharsis, vindication, reparation and compensation.”

Read More...

The Limits of Executive Action for Human Rights


by Henry Krisch, University of Connecticut

“Since 2006, Toledo has found a useful perch in academic and NGO institutions in this country, such as working with the Carter Center on election monitoring. It would have been interesting to hear his views on how his outlook on these matters has been shaped by his American experiences— and how his Peruvian and Indio life may have lead him to see the weaknesses of the American approach to human rights."

Read More...

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

October 2009: Women’s Human Rights

Annotation of

The Women’s Crusade. By Nicholas D. Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn. The New York Times Magazine. August 17, 2009.

~ The Editors

Read More...

"The Female Entrepreneur"?

by Cath Collins, Universidad Diego Portales, Santiago de Chile

“This article begs at least as many questions as it raises, but to my mind the falsest note it strikes has to do with the argument that women’s status as a legitimate development priority is not inherent. Rather, they are a convenient vehicle for targeting because they are responsible, family-centred—self-sacrificing, therefore—and, even better, potential capitalists too.”

Read More...

Violence in the House

by Katherine Hite, Vassar College

"If we are to imagine that another world for women is possible, we need to globalize the atrocities, which mean a fair share of self-implication, confronting our own dirty laundry, putting our house in order as we lecture about what must be done elsewhere."

Read More...

A Few Drops of Oil Will Not be Enough

by Stephen James, La Trobe University

"...but a focus on the individual capacities and self-reliance of women who can by their own imagination, creativity, energy and efforts turn their families and communities around through entrepreneurship is a rather romantic account. While our hearts are warmed by such inspirational stories they are exceptional stories: most women in their shoes do not overcome the extraordinary odds stacked against them."

Read More...

From Outrage to Action

by Henry Krisch, University of Connecticut

“The resistance of political authority, economic privilege and gender-based power and customs will be difficult to overcome. Long term gains will require immediate political costs. Who will pay them? What strategies will provide economic and political tools on a large scale? What ideas will reconcile emerging women’s rights with embedded patriarchic privilege?"

Read More...

Tuesday, September 8, 2009

September 2009: Democratic Republic of Congo: Humanitarian Crisis and the International Community

Annotation of

The Rape of the Congo. By Adam Hochschild. The New York Review of Books. August 13, 2009.

~ The Editors

Read More...